Skip to content
Search
EN

When Does Collecting Debts on Social Media Become Criminal Defamation?

Kotabumi District Court imposed a six-month probation sentence after WPA uploaded two photos of a debtor and called him 'a devil with a human face, a swindler'.

When Does Collecting Debts on Social Media Become Criminal Defamation?
Tirto
Verified Source

Tirto

View Original Report
2 min readRead in Indonesian

The Kotabumi District Court in North Lampung on Thursday (15/10/2026) imposed a probation sentence on WPA for uploading photos and accusations on Facebook against a person who owed him money. The panel of judges found WPA guilty of defaming someone through an electronic system, according to a Tirto report.

The case began when WPA's debt-collection messages went unanswered and his calls were not picked up by the debtor; angry, he uploaded two photos of the victim's face on his Facebook account with a caption calling the victim 'a devil with a human face, a swindler' and accusing him of failing to responsibly repay the debt. The prosecutor charged WPA under Article 45 paragraph (4) in conjunction with Article 27A of Law No. 1 of 2024 on the second amendment to the Electronic Information and Transactions Law (ITE), and in a September 23 demand requested a six-month prison sentence with a detention order.

Judge Teddy Hendrawan Anggar Saputra viewed WPA's act as a spontaneous reaction caused by anger, noting that WPA was a first-time criminal defendant and that four attempts at reconciliation failed because there was no agreement on the Rp24 million settlement money requested by the victim. The final ruling imposed a six-month prison sentence that need not be served, on condition that WPA does not repeat a criminal offense for a year and does not use social media for six months. According to Gufroni, the word 'devil' in WPA's content turned what had been a civil case into a criminal offense.

Legal Context and Criticism

Article 19 paragraph (2) of Law No. 39 of 1999 on Human Rights prohibits imprisonment or detention solely because a person is unable to fulfill a debt obligation. Aan Eko Widiarto stated that displaying a photo and then making remarks that can demean a person's dignity and honor is no longer a civil matter, but defamation.

Abdul Fickar Hadjar, an expert in civil and criminal law at the Faculty of Law, Trisakti University, called the Kotabumi District Court's ruling inappropriate and erroneous because debt is a business or social fact, not a disgrace. He also viewed social media as neutral and said the ruling violated democratic rights by restricting freedom of expression.

Topics

FacebookLampung UtaraPN Kotabumi