Federal Judge Strikes Down Trump Student Visa Rule
Judge Dennis Saylor’s ruling preserved the Duration of Status system for F-1 students, J-1 exchange visitors, and their dependents.
Thedp
A federal court on Monday struck down a Trump administration rule that would have limited how long international students could legally study in the United States. The ruling preserved students’ access to the Duration of Status system, while Penn International Student and Scholar Services said the Penn community did not need to take new action as a result of the ruling. The development was reported by The Daily Pennsylvanian, an independent, student-run newspaper.
What the Court Decided
In a memorandum dated November 16, Judge Dennis Saylor of the U.S. District Court for the District of Massachusetts called the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) policy “arbitrary and capricious.” The proposed final rule would have replaced the Duration of Status system with a fixed four-year admission period for F-1 visa holders, J-1 exchange participants, and their dependents. Under the current rule, most F-1 students and J-1 participants can stay for the length of their academic or exchange program, as long as their immigration status is maintained.
Under the struck-down rule, the admission period would have ended on a specific date. People who needed additional time to complete their program would have had to apply for an Extension of Stay. DHS General Counsel James Percival defended the change by saying a person could come on a student visa, take one class per semester, and then stay in the United States for decades.
However, Saylor found that the rule could effectively bar students from entering to pursue a degree at the same or a lower level than the degree they had already completed. That finding came even though DHS itself acknowledged “legitimate reasons” for pursuing a degree at the same or lower level. Saylor also wrote that DHS’s action conflicted with statutory authority, because the authority to set admission requirements rested with Congress, not the executive branch.
Impact on Students and Universities
Saylor distinguished the agency’s authority to set the time and conditions of nonimmigrant stays from the proposed rule. According to him, the rule had no reasonable connection to that authority and instead sought to prevent or hinder educational opportunities for foreign students that Congress wanted to provide and encourage. For students, the consequence was that the old system remained the basis for their academic stay, not a four-year limit that automatically triggered extension applications.
Penn had previously sent a letter to DHS in October 2025 opposing the policy. Penn administrators argued that the rule would weaken the competitiveness of American education, disrupt nearly all Ph.D. programs, and create large administrative costs for students and universities. In September, international students at the university also told The Daily Pennsylvanian that increased uncertainty had already changed their career plans.
The court found that the federal government failed to consider provisions in the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS) that could achieve goals similar to the Final Rule. Saylor cited the example of using SEVIS to identify abuse, including “pay-to-stay” fraud. He called the proposed system “unreviewable” and “completely discretionary,” and said it did not adequately explain how the policy would improve efforts to combat fraud.
According to Saylor, DHS should at least have compared SEVIS improvements with the large costs and limited benefits of the Final Rule, but it did not. For international students, other enrollment guidance remained in effect, including the request for Curricular Practical Training authorization. Penn International Student and Scholar Services said it would continue to monitor developments and provide timely guidance because further legal proceedings remained possible.
Topics
Read more
#Dennis Saylor · #Department of Homeland Security · #Donald Trump
- Trump to Meet Xi and Putin in Shenzhen on November 19
- Trump and Qatar's emir discuss de-escalation amid Hormuz tanker hits
- Democrats Take Control of U.S. Congress, Blow to Trump
- US to Remove South Africa and Rwanda from Agoa
- Trump Denies Plan for Military Strike on Iran After 2026 US Election
- Trump Angry Over Obama's Jab About White House Renovation