House Commission II Struggles to Translate 22 Constitutional Court Rulings into Election Bill
The rulings intersect with regional government, regional election, and political party laws, while several provisions must take effect before the 2029 Election.
Nasional
House Commission II acknowledged difficulty translating 22 Constitutional Court (MK) rulings into revisions to Law Number 7 of 2017 on Elections. According to a Kompas.com report, Deputy Chair of House Commission II Dede Yusuf Macan Effendi raised the issue at a public hearing on drafting the Election Bill on 11 November 2026, based on a TVR Parlemen broadcast.
Constitutional Court rulings intersect with several laws
Dede said the 22 election-related rulings needed to be incorporated into the latest legal framework for elections. The task was not isolated because several rulings intersected with Law Number 23 of 2014 on Regional Government, Law Number 10 of 2016 on Regional Elections, and Law Number 2 of 2011 on Political Parties.
House Commission II also faced issues involving the parliamentary threshold, the presidential threshold, and separating national and regional elections. One ruling requiring translation was Constitutional Court Decision Number 62/PUU-XXII/2024, which removed the 20 percent presidential threshold to guarantee equal political rights and popular sovereignty for all political parties participating in elections.
Parliamentary threshold must change before 2029
Through Decision Number 116/PUU-XXI/2023, the Constitutional Court established five prerequisites for determining the parliamentary threshold for the 2029 Election. The new provisions must be designed for continued use, maintain the proportionality of the proportional electoral system so votes are not wasted without conversion into House seats, and encourage political party consolidation.
The ruling originated from a challenge to the 4 percent parliamentary threshold in Article 414 paragraph (1) of Law Number 7 of 2017, which the Constitutional Court partially granted on 29 February 2023. The Constitutional Court stated that the 4 percent threshold must be changed before the 2029 Election, with the change completed before election administration stages begin.
The amendment process must involve all parties concerned with election administration through meaningful public participation, including election-participating parties without representation in the House. House Commission II stated that it was conducting meaningful participation by involving civil society and academics to seek ideas and options on several issues.
Dede requested input from professors and academics on concepts that could be aligned for the benefit of the future Election Law. For voters and political parties, developments requiring monitoring included the wording of the new threshold, presidential nomination rules after the presidential threshold was removed, and regulatory readiness before the 2029 Election stages.
Topics
Read more
#Komisi II DPR RI · #Mahkamah Konstitusi · #Pemilu 2029
- Commission II Member Proposes 2 Options for KPU Selection Committee
- Election Bill Working Committee Starts Work November 2, 2026
- Denny Indrayana: Gibran No Longer Meets VP Requirements
- Constitutional Law Expert: Gibran's VP Position Should Lapse
- Expert Urges DPR to Process VP Gibran's Fate After MK and MA Rulings
- Kaesang Leads PSI Depok Consolidation, Targets Six DPRD Seats