MUI Highlights Insults Against Ulama, Says Criticism Must Be Civil
MUI said many insults emerged within the Muslim community and urged broader religious understanding to prevent division.
Detik
The Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) highlighted the increasing number of alleged insults and attacks against ulama that had recently emerged in society. MUI said Islam still allowed constructive criticism, but it had to be delivered properly and uphold etiquette. This approach was considered important so correction did not become an attack that intensified conflict.
MUI Interfaith Harmony Commission Chairman Kiai Zainuddin Daulay conveyed the view while speaking with MUI Digital in Jakarta on Monday, 16 November 2026. He stressed that correction and feedback intended to build had never been prohibited under Islamic law. He said the approach was consistent with the teaching “watawasau bil haqqi watawasau bis sabr,” meaning to advise one another in truth and patience.
Series of Cases and Public Responses
MUI's concerns emerged after several cases involving insults against religious figures came to light. In early November 2026, YouTuber Herri Pras was reported to the Riau Regional Police for allegedly insulting Ustaz Abdul Somad and Ustaz Adi Hidayat through his content. Herri later admitted that his delivery had been too harsh and publicly apologized.
Previously, in October 2026, a video containing insults against the late Abah Guru Sekumpul, KH Muhammad Zaini bin Abdul Ghani, went viral in Banjarmasin and triggered a gathering of hundreds of residents. That same month, three Facebook accounts in Sape, West Nusa Tenggara, were also reported to authorities for allegedly insulting local ulama. In several recent incidents, public anger even led to crowds directly confronting alleged perpetrators before legal proceedings began.
Roots of Friction and MUI's Steps
Kiai Zainuddin reminded the public that shortcomings or mistakes requiring correction should be addressed through bil hikmah, or wisdom, and mau'izhatul hasanah, or good advice, without hurting feelings or offending others. From a fundamental Islamic perspective, evil could not be answered with evil; goodness was the recommended response. For society, this message positioned criticism as a means of improvement, not justification for humiliating others.
He observed that friction and attacks against ulama had recently occurred more often within the Muslim community itself, rather than being driven by interfaith sentiment. He said the condition was inseparable from the rapid flow of global information and intense competition in the economic, political, social, and cultural sectors, which had affected the decline of religious moral values. In the digital space, these changes made the way people spoke and the impact of a statement important parts of the issue under scrutiny.
Beyond external factors, the main trigger of internal conflict within the Muslim community was considered rooted in narrow religious understanding. Such a worldview could make someone believe their group's doctrine was the most correct, refuse to understand others' beliefs, and prioritize symbols over the essence of Islam as rahmatan lil alamin. From this attitude, Kiai Zainuddin said, came practices of declaring fellow Muslims heretical, misguided, or infidels.
MUI considered the issue urgent because the potential for division could weaken the Muslim community. As a follow-up, Kiai Zainuddin urged MUI's Da'wah Commission and Brotherhood Commission to design a program to broaden religious understanding. The program was intended to help people speak more wisely and respect differences within the community.
Topics
Read more
#Jakarta · #MUI · #Ustaz Abdul Somad
- Jakarta Government Supports Police Anti-Drug Efforts
- Senayan City Responds to Pramono’s Ultimatum on New Road
- Metro Jaya Police Deploy Humanistic Security for 74 Jakarta Demos
- Ali Sadikin and Hoegeng Named National Heroes
- Indonesian Navy Deploys Personnel to Jakarta for Security and Training
- Former Jampidsus Febrie Adriansyah's Exception Rejected