Drought Theory of Maya Collapse Now Questioned
Research at Itzan and 294 Belize sites shows collapse patterns that did not always follow drought.
Mediaindonesia
For the past three decades, scientists have believed drought was the single answer to the collapse of Maya civilization. This theory says a series of historic droughts between 760 and 910 CE triggered mass exoduses from major cities in an area now covering Mexico, Belize, Guatemala, El Salvador, and Honduras.
Uneven Evidence
Last year's research found the Itzan site in Guatemala was largely abandoned without ever experiencing drought. Another study published last September of 294 Maya sites in Belize showed the opposite result, because sites that received more rainfall were abandoned earlier than drier regions.
Historical Context and Sources of Evidence
The Maya were not a single empire but a network of city-states connected through trade and warfare. Between 760 and 930 CE, their major cities began to fade one by one. Alec McLellan, an anthropologist at Western University in Ontario, said debate over climate's effect on Maya civilization remains intense among academics. "There used to be one easy answer, and then we came and made it complicated," he said.
Most written Maya records were burned by Spanish missionaries, so knowledge is gathered mainly from archaeology, carvings, and statues, according to Matt Waters of Auburn University. Although evidence of extreme drought in the Yucatán Peninsula does exist, especially from oxygen isotope studies at Lake Chichancanab in the mid-1990s, researchers now see it as one part of a larger puzzle.
Drought as an Indirect Trigger
Benjamin Gwinneth, a geographer at the University of Montreal, argues drought may not have been strong enough to destroy Maya civilization on its own, but it could worsen other causes of decline or create new problems. Because Maya city-states depended on one another, indirect effects of drought in one region, such as political instability, warfare, and mass migration, could spread to regions that actually had enough water.
Lessons for Climate Crisis
Maya civilization is considered an apt analogy for understanding how today's climate crisis can interact with existing social and political problems. Descendants of the Maya still live in the region today.
Topics
Read more
#belize · #guatemala · #itzan