Skip to content
Search
EN

BYD Allegedly Copied Defender, JLR Ordered to Destroy Documents

The District Court of The Hague gave JLR 24 hours to destroy all materials seized from BYD offices.

BYD Allegedly Copied Defender, JLR Ordered to Destroy Documents
Oto
Verified Source

Oto

View Original Report
3 min readRead in Indonesian

The District Court of The Hague ordered Jaguar Land Rover (JLR) to destroy all materials seized from BYD offices within 24 hours after the ruling was read. According to detikOto, JLR also faced a fine of up to 500,000 euros for noncompliance. The ruling halted JLR’s direct use of the seized documents in proceedings alleging that BYD copied the Land Rover Defender’s design.

Seizure in the Netherlands

Bailiffs acting for JLR raided BYD offices in the Netherlands after BYD was accused of copying the Land Rover Defender’s design. In August, JLR carried out an ex parte seizure of digital files, without prior notice to the defendant, at BYD offices in Schiedam and Hoofddorp. The move aimed to secure the files before BYD could potentially delete them.

JLR accused the BYD Ti7 of not only copying the Defender’s exterior design but also dismantling one Defender for reverse engineering. However, no evidence of intellectual property infringement existed when the action took place. BYD’s lawyers called JLR’s move a fishing expedition, while JLR reportedly obtained Ti7 development documents and BYD financial data.

The Court’s Reasoning

The judge found that taking the documents was not yet necessary to prove an infringement at that stage. The Court also noted that there was no dispute that BYD had not offered or sold the Ti7 in the European Union market. Therefore, the alleged infringement had not caused JLR losses in the region.

The Ti7 was often compared with the Land Rover Defender because it reached five meters in length, similar to the Defender 110. The BYD model was also said to sell for much less than the cheapest Defender 110. The comparisons of size and price drew attention in the design dispute, although the ruling did not state that an intellectual property infringement had occurred.

Design Dispute History

The Ti7 case was not JLR’s first dispute with a Chinese automaker over alleged design copying. One earlier case involved the LandWind X7, a vehicle with striking similarities to the Range Rover Evoque. In that case, JLR ultimately won its lawsuit against the vehicle manufacturer.

For BYD, the destruction order meant that JLR could not retain the seized Ti7 development documents and financial data under this ruling. For JLR, noncompliance could trigger a fine of up to 500,000 euros, making the 24-hour limit the key deadline after the ruling was read. The next developments will depend on enforcement of the destruction order and legal proceedings concerning the alleged similarities between the Ti7 and the Defender.

Topics

BYDDen HaagJaguar Land RoverLand Rover Defender

Read more

#BYD · #Den Haag · #Jaguar Land Rover